A Systematic Review to Summarise and Appraise the Reporting of Surgical Innovation: a Case Study in Robotic Roux-en-Y Gastric Bypass
Articolo
Data di Pubblicazione:
2024
Citazione:
A Systematic Review to Summarise and Appraise the Reporting of Surgical Innovation: a Case Study in Robotic Roux-en-Y Gastric Bypass / Huttman, M.M., Smith, A.N., Robertson, H.F., Purves, R., Biggs, S.E., Dewi, F., Dixon, L.K., Kirkham, E.N., Jones, C.S., Ramirez, J., Scroggie, D.L., Pathak, S., Blencowe, N.S., Null, N., Main, B., Blazeby, J., Dawson, S., Wilkinson, A., Jones, A., Abbas, A., et al.. - In: OBESITY SURGERY. - ISSN 0960-8923. - 34:8(2024), pp. 3058-3070. [10.1007/s11695-024-07329-8]
Abstract:
Robotic Roux-en-Y gastric bypass (RRYGB) is an innovative alternative to traditional laparoscopic approaches. Literature has been published investigating its safety/efficacy; however, the quality of reporting is uncertain. This systematic review used the Idea, Development, Exploration, Assessment and Long-term follow-up (IDEAL) framework to assess the reporting quality of available literature. A narrative summary was formulated, assessing how comprehensively governance/ethics, patient selection, demographics, surgeon expertise/training, technique description and outcomes were reported. Forty-seven studies published between 2005 and 2024 were included. There was incomplete/inconsistent reporting of governance/ethics, patient selection, surgeon expertise/training and technique description, with heterogenous outcome reporting. RRYGB reporting was poor and did not align with IDEAL guidance. Robust prospective studies reporting findings using IDEAL/other guidance are required to facilitate safe widespread adoption of RRYGB and other surgical innovations.
Tipologia CRIS:
1.1 Articolo in rivista
Keywords:
Bariatric surgery; IDEAL framework; Innovation; Outcome reporting; Robotic surgery; Roux-en-Y gastric bypass
Elenco autori:
Huttman, Marc M.; Smith, Alexander N.; Robertson, Harry F.; Purves, Rory; Biggs, Sarah E.; Dewi, Ffion; Dixon, Lauren K.; Kirkham, Emily N.; Jones, Conor S.; Ramirez, Jozel; Scroggie, Darren L.; Pathak, Samir; Blencowe, Natalie S.; Null, Null; Main, Barry; Blazeby, Jane; Dawson, Sarah; Wilkinson, Aimee; Jones, Annabel; Abbas, Aya; Turner, Benedict; Thomas, Charlie; Henshall, David; Boden, Eleanor; Gull, Emma; Sewart, Emma; Wood, Fergus; Loro, Francesca; Hollowood, Freya; Fowler, George; Higginbotham, George; Sellers, Grace; Hughes, Ioan; Handa, Ishita; Leandro, Lorna; Paynter, Louisa; Huppler, Lucy; Gourbault, Lysander; Wijeyaratne, Manuk; Dewhurst, Maximilian; Shah, Max; Kiandee, Miraen; Dada, Mo; Brewster, Oliver; Lok, Pat; Winayak, Rahul; Ranat, Reesha; Lawrence, Ruby; Millar, Ryan; Lawday, Sam; Dalmia, Sanjush; Rozwadowski, Sophie; Robinson, Tanya; Perra, Teresa; Leow, Tjun Wei; Brankin-Frisby, Tom; Baker, William; Hurst, William; Embury-Young, Ysabelle; Vallance, Abigail; Young, Amber; Zucker, Ben; Hoffmann, Christin; Richards, Hollie; Olivier, James; Rees, Jonathan; Lee, Keng Siang; Macefield, Rhiannon; Cousins, Sian
Link alla scheda completa:
Pubblicato in: